SIGN IN SAVED 0

Kinzie Island Sanibel Florida Homes for Sale

Naples Florida Real Estate

Kinzie Island Sanibel Real Estate

Homes For Sale2$2M - $5M
Condos For Sale1$3.9M
Sold ( Past 6 Months )1$2.2M
Last updated at 10:24pm 02/14/2026

  1. Main
  2. Sanibel Real Estate
  3. Kinzie Island Homes for Sale
1 - 3 of 3
Previous
1
Next


Save this Search Compare Properties
Get Pre-Qualified

$4,999,750
View Details

Kinzie Island

505 Kinzie Island Ct, Sanibel, FL 33957

Homes - 4,777 ft² / 7,039 ft² - 4 Car Garage

5 Bed / 4 Baths / 1 Half / Pool / Spa

Built 1990
Kinzie Island Sanibel Homes for Sale: Imagine living on Sanibel Island… within an island. Welcome to Kinzie Island, a rare gated enclave on Sanibel’s desirable East End, where privacy, resort-style amenities, and timeless island charm create the ultimate coastal retreat. This fully reimagined residence has undergone a top-to-bottom renovation, offering peace of mind and modern coastal elegance throughout. The home features new insulation, drywall, interior paint, engineered French oak flooring, recessed LED lighting, new doors, trim, and baseboards, along with upgraded electrical, plumbing, and mechanical systems. The chef’s kitchen is a showstopper—completely redesigned with custom soft-close cabinetry, quartz countertops, subway/mosaic backsplash, a large island, and all-new stainless steel appliances, including a 48” induction range. The layout was thoughtfully reconfigured to enhance flow and function, ideal for entertaining or everyday island living. Each bathroom has been beautifully updated, including a luxurious primary suite with custom tile wet-room shower, glass enclosure, freestanding soaking tub, rain shower, double vanity, and upgraded fixtures. Guest baths and the powder room feature new vanities, tile surrounds, flooring, lighting, and modern finishes throughout. Behind the scenes, no detail was overlooked: three new high-efficiency HVAC systems, smart thermostats, new ductwork, upgraded electrical panels and sub-panels, impact windows and doors, standing-seam metal roof, new gutters, and refreshed plumbing with PEX—all designed for efficiency, durability, and comfort. Outdoors, enjoy fresh landscaping, new sod and plantings, repaired irrigation, exterior lighting, new screening and railings, and a beautifully refreshed exterior. The garage includes epoxy flooring, impact garage doors with smart openers, flood vents, and a bonus room with slider—perfect for a studio, gym, or flex space. Island charm defines life here. Enjoy peaceful beach walks, world-class shelling, boating adventures, and island living at its best. Take in beautiful views of the Gulf, savor relaxing morning sunrises, and unwind beneath spectacular evening sunset skies—the essence of the Sanibel lifestyle. This home is ideally suited for full-time or retirement living, while effortlessly accommodating family gatherings and visiting friends—offering comfort, privacy, and refined luxury for every occasion. Kinzie Island amenities are unmatched for such an intimate community: • Boat dockage • Resort-style pool with lap area • Pickleball & tennis courts • Shuffleboard & bocce ball courts • Beach storage • Secure, gated entry All just a short distance to the beach, and moments from Sanibel’s shopping, dining, bike paths, and natural beauty. A rare opportunity to own in one of Sanibel’s few gated communities—an island within an island—where luxury, lifestyle, and location meet.



$1,995,000
View Details

Kinzie Island NEW

500 Kinzie Island Ct, Sanibel, FL 33957

Homes - 2,696 ft² / 6,383 ft² - 2 Car Garage

3+Den / 3 Baths

Built 1995
Kinzie Island Sanibel Homes for Sale: On the tranquil shores of Sanibel Island lies a private enclave few even know exists, a secluded “island within an island” known as Kinzie Island. Tucked behind a gated, bridged entrance and laced with serene canals, this intimate community of just 22distinguished residences offers a rare blend of exclusivity, coastal beauty, and effortless luxury. Just moments from the powder-soft, shell-strewn beaches that have made Sanibel world-famous, this canal-front residence captures the essence of refined island living. A private dock and boat lift extend your backyard into open water, inviting spontaneous sunset cruises, fishing excursions, or leisurely days exploring the Gulf. Inside, the home unfolds with warmth and intention. The kitchen serves as both centerpiece and gathering place, anchored by a professional-grade gas range and an expansive island wrapped in rich butcher-block accents. Here, culinary creativity meets conversation, a space equally suited for elegant dinner parties and relaxed mornings with coffee and sea breezes drifting through open doors. The adjacent dining room adds a layer of ambiance, where a statement fireplace casts a welcoming glow, turning everyday meals into memorable evenings. Throughout the home, design and livability move in harmony, beautiful yet unpretentious, polished yet comfortable. Outdoor living is woven into every level. Sip morning coffee from the welcoming front balcony, host sunset cocktails on the spacious screened lanai overlooking the canal, or retreat to the third-floor sundeck where sunshine and salty air become part of your daily rhythm. Lush tropical landscaping provides a natural curtain of privacy, enhancing the sense that this is your own secluded retreat. Yet the lifestyle extends far beyond your front door. Residents enjoy access to an impressive collection of resort-style amenities designed for both recreation and connection: a heated lap pool for morning swims, clay tennis court, pickleball and bocce courts, and classic shuffleboard for leisurely afternoons. Just across the street, an exceptional private beach club elevates the experience even further, offering a fitness center, convenient beach storage, restrooms, and a dedicated path leading directly to the shoreline. It’s a seamless transition from home to sand; no crowds, no hassle, just the rhythm of waves and the sweep of open horizon. This is more than a residence. It is a sanctuary shaped by water, wrapped in privacy, and defined by a level of coastal living rarely found and even more rarely available.



$2,195,000
View Details

Kinzie Island

519 Kinzie Island Ct, Sanibel, FL 33957

Homes - 3,018 ft² / 6,638 ft² - 3 Car Garage

4+Den / 3 Baths / 1 Half / Pool

Built 1991
Kinzie Island Sanibel Homes Under Contract: Experience the ultimate blend of luxury and coastal charm in the exclusive gated community known as Kinzie Island, an island within an island on Sanibel Island, where unmatched amenities and a welcoming atmosphere create the perfect island retreat. This highly elevated 4-bedroom, 3.5-bath home is located on Sanibel's convenient east end just steps to white sand beaches and a short bike ride to the Historical Sanibel Lighthouse. This light-filled retreat boasts soaring ceilings, impact windows and doors, newer roof and an open-concept design that maximizes space and natural light. As you enter the home you are suddenly moved by a a beautiful foyer and the huge greatroom area. The chef’s kitchen is a show stopper with double islands featuring leather granite and quartz counter tops, a gas range, a farmhouse sink, and a walk-in pantry.— The spacious VIP suite is a sanctuary with a beautiful bath, double vanities, a soaking tub, and a extra large walk-in closet. The separete guest suites are generous and private. The quality to detail, real oak flooring, decorative tile floors, incrediable lighting, beautiful fixtures, are all amazing. Outside you will relax and enjoy a beautiful private pool area, incredaiable out door deck space a, and more. The home also features a 3-car garage and abundant storage. Kinzie Island is like no other! The Community amenities are unparalleled, featuring private boat dockage, deeded beach access, Beachside private facilities and storage lockers, a fitness room, Community pool with facilities, pickleball and tennis courts, bocce, shuffleboard, and a dog park. This is a fantastic lifestyle enjoyed by only 22 private residences. Kinzie Island, an island within an island on Sanibel Island.




1 - 3 of 3
Previous
1
Next


Contact Us
Need professional assistance selling your property at Kinzie Island Sanibel? Find out how an Area Specialist can help to generate more property exposure in order to get the most money for your investment in the least amount of time.Contact Us.
*Just Listed: new properties that came on the market within the last 30 days.
*Decrease/Increase: listing values that are being recorded within the last 30 days.
*Foreclosures/Short Sale: Please note, all properties are subject to bank approval. Buyers must be pre-approved or show proof of funds before submitting an offer.

The data relating to real estate for sale/lease on this web site come in part from a cooperative data exchange program of the multiple listing service (MLS) in which this real estate firm (Broker) participates. The properties displayed may not be all of the properties in the MLS's database, or all of the properties listed with Brokers participating in the cooperative data exchange program. Properties listed by Brokers other than this Broker are marked with either the listing Broker's logo or name or the MLS name or a logo provided by the MLS. Detailed information about such properties includes the name of the listing Brokers. Information provided is thought to be reliable but is not guaranteed to be accurate; you are advised to verify facts that are important to you. No warranties, expressed or implied, are provided for the data herein, or for their use or interpretation by the user. The Florida Association of Realtors and its cooperating MLSs do not create, control or review the property data displayed herein and take no responsibility for the content of such records. Federal law prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status or national origin in the sale, rental or financing of housing.